In my opinion-neither-keep your guns and find someone who needs work done and earn your new gun on the side-I'd go for the Single-Six-----I wish I had a dollar for every gun I ever traded off and have lived to regret....you can always make some money---offer to work for the store that's got it a few Saturdays cleaning guns or painting or something---lots of people will fall over backwards to find that someone is willing to work....betchacan earn it before the month's out!!