I, too, have the proverbial box of holsters. No one holster fits all of my needs, that is why I got a box of them! I have several El Paso Saddelry holsters. I have three #77 Tortilla holsters, one for my Blackhawk 5 and 1/2 inch, one for my P89, and one for a SP101. I also have an EL Paso Tom Threepersons crossdraw holster for my 7 1/2 inch SuperBlackhawk. Got a Hunter holster that will fit most any gun I got, but it is not ideal. For Concealed carry I use the #77, or I have a Don Hume IWB holster for my P89 that is an outstanding holster, stays open even if weapon is drawn. Now, I need to get another holster for my 3 1/2 Birds Head Vaquero! It is a neverending quest!