Even if the gun would fit, some people are very picky to what the fit feels like. I highly suggest going down to your local gun dealer and holding a few so you can judge for yourself the fit & feel. If everyone liked the same fit & feel, we would only have two guns to choose from.
My personal preference: I like the older 'block' Ruger autos best, you can't get better than a P89, P90 or P91! I probably feel this way because I have large hands, and I have better control over something I can get a good grip on.
I am not 100% sure, but I think the P95s are slightly smaller, so if the P89 is too thick try a P95.