Ruger Forum banner

Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 68 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
188 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Just when I had given up on searching for the "one CLP to rule them all" I stumbled across this in a YouTube playlist. Weapons Sheild. Whether or not its the best cleaner, I use JB and Kroil in the bore anyway so to me thats irrelevant. Also, though I havent watched it yet I'll take his word for it on corrosion protection, anyway this video about summed it up for me showing how superior this is as a lubrication. It seems like the ultimate bore lube at a minimum.

Also, I wondered if I just wasted $25 on the Militec-1 I just bought and so far triple heat treated one firearm, and it turns out that Weapons Shield is made by the same guy who originally did Militec-1. Only this formula doesnt require heat treating. So yes, I did waste my money and bought a $25 bottle of this, but this one is 16 oz instead of 4.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lcBu6q61G3M
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
49 Posts
Clp is all i use never used any other and thats all the military uses unless the changed. If its good for them its good for me
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
134 Posts
you guys and your silly clp/magic poofies/huh?
just use atf yup good old dexron II or heck even Dexron I if you find a barrel of it or you could go ultra modern and use any old synthetic motor oil you can find.........
if i had a nickle for every dollar you all waste on "poofie lube" my forced retirement would be splendid!!
now ill sit back and wait for the frog lube bunch to croak on in.....

these are guns
not turbine engines, no high temp, no high stress
oil,shoot,clean,oil,shoot,clean thats all you need and not very often either


just my 3 cents worth
go ahead let me have it! smack me about!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
188 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Clp is all i use never used any other and thats all the military uses unless the changed. If its good for them its good for me
They have had a lot of issues with clp in the military. Mostly with jamming of the M4. Largely due to the sandbox effect.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,280 Posts
you guys and your silly clp/magic poofies/huh?
just use atf yup good old dexron II or heck even Dexron I if you find a barrel of it or you could go ultra modern and use any old synthetic motor oil you can find.........
if i had a nickle for every dollar you all waste on "poofie lube" my forced retirement would be splendid!!
now ill sit back and wait for the frog lube bunch to croak on in.....

these are guns
not turbine engines, no high temp, no high stress
oil,shoot,clean,oil,shoot,clean thats all you need and not very often either


just my 3 cents worth
go ahead let me have it! smack me about!
Thank you. Very well stated.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,915 Posts
I have used Weapons Shield and it works just fine. Also, Ballistol works great on my ARs. I liked the old Break Free, the military issue stuff, before they sold out to another company. After trying all those, I always end up going back to Frog Lube.

I suppose any of them will do a good job of lubing, even Mobil 1.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,231 Posts
you guys and your silly clp/magic poofies/huh?
just use atf yup good old dexron II or heck even Dexron I if you find a barrel of it or you could go ultra modern and use any old synthetic motor oil you can find.........
if i had a nickle for every dollar you all waste on "poofie lube" my forced retirement would be splendid!!
now ill sit back and wait for the frog lube bunch to croak on in.....

these are guns
not turbine engines, no high temp, no high stress
oil,shoot,clean,oil,shoot,clean thats all you need and not very often either


just my 3 cents worth
go ahead let me have it! smack me about!

Tranny fluid is what you use? Never thought of that. I did "croak" just buy some "croak" frog lube and I am pleased. I think will pick a gun or two and try Drextron 11. You are never too old to learn, but I am getting close.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
4,202 Posts
Oh good. Another lube thread. Yay.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
321 Posts
you guys and your silly clp/magic poofies/huh?
just use atf yup good old dexron II or heck even Dexron I if you find a barrel of it or you could go ultra modern and use any old synthetic motor oil you can find.........
if i had a nickle for every dollar you all waste on "poofie lube" my forced retirement would be splendid!!
now ill sit back and wait for the frog lube bunch to croak on in.....

these are guns
not turbine engines, no high temp, no high stress
oil,shoot,clean,oil,shoot,clean thats all you need and not very often either


just my 3 cents worth
go ahead let me have it! smack me about!
Well said. I still use Mobil one synthetic wheel bearing greese on my 1911. Every bit as good as slide glide and may, in fact, be the same stuff... ;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,891 Posts
Clp is all i use never used any other and thats all the military uses unless the changed. If its good for them its good for me
Are you talking about Breakfree CLP from Safariland? There's a hundred products out there that use CLP in their name and someone always says they just use CLP but as far as I can tell there isn't a product that just goes by "CLP". I've always wondered about that...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,735 Posts
Check out the testing run in the following post and see how your favorite fared...

I would say they each have very different purposes. Eezox does not seem to have any lubricating properties from my observations of using it. It seems to flash off pretty quick and leave a very fine film that does a good job protecting metal. Break Free CLP is a better lubricant than I have found it to be a cleaner (solvent) or protectant, but I have avoided it outside the military. Here are three links I find useful:

Lubricants 101 by Grant Cunningham

Comprehensive Corrosion Test: 46 Products Compared


Bore Cleaning Methods and Materials
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
188 Posts
Discussion Starter #14
Really the only pressured surfaces in a gun are the action if its semi/full auto, and the inside of the barrel.

Interestingly, Weapons Shield seems to reduce the most friction, but cause the most drag according to the test done....maybe its thicker so its just a slower moving oil.

I feel like the ultimate test would be to test bullet velocities with barrels treated with each type of oil
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,280 Posts
Really the only pressured surfaces in a gun are the action if its semi/full auto, and the inside of the barrel.

Interestingly, Weapons Shield seems to reduce the most friction, but cause the most drag according to the test done....maybe its thicker so its just a slower moving oil.

I feel like the ultimate test would be to test bullet velocities with barrels treated with each type of oil
Huh? Um... you don't want oil in your barrel when you're shooting a gun. That's a good way to get at best a barrel bulge and at worst a kaboom.

The reason there are so many products for guns that so many people rave about as being the best is that they pretty much all work. Heck, with some guns, like AK's or Glocks, I'm pretty sure you could use bacon grease and not only would they work fine, but it wouldn't hurt them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
49 Posts
The military stuff just says clp i got a gallon back around 2000 from the unit i was in and still using it didn't cost me any thing about out. I have heard people using clean motor oil not trans fluid but it does have more cleaning properties to it. I will give trans fluid a try when i run out of clp thanx for the tip
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
188 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
Huh? Um... you don't want oil in your barrel when you're shooting a gun. That's a good way to get at best a barrel bulge and at worst a kaboom.

The reason there are so many products for guns that so many people rave about as being the best is that they pretty much all work. Heck, with some guns, like AK's or Glocks, I'm pretty sure you could use bacon grease and not only would they work fine, but it wouldn't hurt them.
Something along the sort of a dry lube. Had you watched the video before throwing your .02 in you'd see that even when wiped off completely this stuff still beats any other lube there is. Having a dry lube won't hurt your barrel. If it did, I would have ruined all my guns already and so would have all the other champion shooters who put things like graphite in their barrel.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,030 Posts
I have a lot of different stuff and basically simple oils and Hoppes is all you need it seems.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
583 Posts
Cleaning/Lube products always generate a lot of opinions. That being said, I've used Weapon Shield for a few years and have had excellent results. It doesn't require a lot of product (a little goes a long way).
 
1 - 20 of 68 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top