At liberty ,
I understand your thinking on this and have contemplated the same scenario with our bears around here . My thought process usually goes like this , " if a bear is in my face , ( quite literally perhaps ) , I'd probably be better off with my gp-100 . But I want more than a 357 magnum ,maybe my smith & wesson 625 mountain gun in 45 colt ( with my El Paso saddlery tanker holster ) , but I love my single actions , so maybe "... and then I try to decide between my stainless or blued 44 special flattops depending on weather . These are in a crossroads holster as well .
Our national forest starts 5 miles from my house and I spend a lot of time in it . 2 years ago I came right up on a HUGE cinnamon colored boar that was eating on a gut pile , maybe 15-20 yards away , got my attention right away �� !
Any of the above guns would've been fine , I was carrying a blackhawk in 45 colt at the time , been thinking about getting a 4"Redhawk ever since .
It never ends , haha .