I bought my first revolver a couple weeks ago. A New Model Blackhawk Lipsey's Flattop with a 4.62" barrel chambered in .357 magnum. I've been testing out different loads looking for one I like. I was wondering what other folks have found that fits their needs.
I'm specifically looking for a 125gr hollow point.
Here's what I've tried so far with some 5-shot chronograph testing:
I also have a Black Hills and a Remington load on the way.
The Hornady Critical Defense showed the most consistency, but I shot the best with the Barnes loading. The Underwood was wildly inconsistent. Two of the shots from the 5-round group were almost 200fps apart. It is fun to shoot though. The Buffalo stuff subjectively had the least recoil.
What are you using?
I'm specifically looking for a 125gr hollow point.
Here's what I've tried so far with some 5-shot chronograph testing:
| Load | Average fps | Standard deviation |
| Barnes 125gr XPD | 1420.6 fps | 29.25 |
| Underwood 125gr XTP | 1575 fps | 59.55 |
| Buffalo 125gr XPB (19H) | 1384.2 fps | 29.13 |
| Hornady Critical Defense 125gr FTX | 1416.8 fps | 25.77 |
I also have a Black Hills and a Remington load on the way.
The Hornady Critical Defense showed the most consistency, but I shot the best with the Barnes loading. The Underwood was wildly inconsistent. Two of the shots from the 5-round group were almost 200fps apart. It is fun to shoot though. The Buffalo stuff subjectively had the least recoil.
What are you using?
