Ruger Forum banner

Is it necessary to line up the cylinder after closing?

7.5K views 14 replies 14 participants last post by  conditionyellow  
#1 · (Edited)
When I close the cylinder on my LCR, I usually turn it until it clicks and lines up. When I deliberately mis-aligned it to see what happens, it looks like it lines up correctly to the next chamber when pulling the trigger.

So is it necessary to turn the cylinder until it clicks/lines up? It bugs me when the cylinder does not go in perfectly the first time, but I want to get out of this bad habit if I don't need to be doing it, especially if my life may be on the line some day.

I tried to look this up on Google, but I couldn't seem to find any specific answers
 
#2 ·
I carried a revolver as a duty weapon for 10 years and still carry one concealed. I always make sure that the cylinder is locked in place after I load it. I even did it on the qualifying range under time limits and stress runs. I think it's better to take a quick second to make sure. Chances are the cylinder will automatically line up and lock when you pull the trigger, but I have never tried it and I'd rather be sure than have a possible accident.
 
#3 ·
I always, by habit, just turn the cylinder so it locks up after I load the gun.......it takes a split second, and it satisifies my "gun OCD" because I couldn't stand it if the chambers were not lined up the way they should be on my carry revolver:)

But, you don't have to. We are revolver aficionados and avid shooters, so we have our little habits and quirks. The hand will simply move up and push the ratchet tooth so the cylinder rotates into lockup regardless of whether the cylinder is locked up or not.

Think of the millions and millions of "non gun" people who have used revolvers over the years.......security guards, police officers, etc. not all of them are "gun savvy" and I guarantee many millions of wheelguns have been reloaded on qualifying ranges or in life or death scenarios without locking the cylinder up after closing and the guns have functioned fine.
 
#15 ·
I have read that the S&W Bodyguard .38 revolver has to be rotated into lockup, or it won't carry up right.
That happend to me when I had one. While target shooting my body guard just "clicked" once when I didn't lock it in. To test it I emptied it and proved to myself that it had to be locked in.
 
#12 ·
In just about all revolvers, you can find a "dead spot" where the pawl (AKA hand) will stub on the cylinder ratchet rather than rotating the cylinder. Usually this dead spot is only about a degree of cylinder rotation wide so odds are with a 6 shot cylinder (60 degrees of rotation per chamber), you have a 59 out of 60 odds that the cylinder will rotate properly when you pull the trigger or cock the hammer. Even though the odds are slim, it's still worth indexing your cylinder each time. Nothing would excite you more than to pull your gun in a self defense situation and find the trigger won't pull back. I always index the cylinders on all revolvers ... that's the way they were designed to operate so that's the best procedure.